Emerging Markets Debt Bomb

Business and investment cycles follow predictable patterns, starting out with pessimism and plenty of idle capacity and ending with optimism and the economy running above potential. But, every cycle also has its particularities. In the case of emerging markets, this current investment cycle is characterized by a very large accumulation of debt.

While emerging market stocks have performed very poorly compared to the U.S. market since 2012 and are now relatively undervalued, they are likely to be constrained by this debt accumulation. Typically, a new period of outperformance for emerging markets would be marked by new capital inflows and credit expansion, but given the rapid debt accumulation of recent years this may not happen this time. In fact, under current conditions of dollar strength, rising interest rates and weak commodity prices, this debt load is proving to be a heavy burden for many countries and causing stock markets to fall further.

Of course, the reason that this cycle is proving to be so different is the unprecedented and sustained Quantitative Easing (QE) programs pursued by the central banks of the world’s main financial centers since 2010. The long period of extraordinarily low interest rates motivated investors to “chase” for yield where ever they could find it and banks and corporations around the emerging market world were more than happy to oblige them. As QE is now being unwound and interest rates are rising, emerging market borrowers are having to refinance at much higher rates. This new trend of rising rates is being compounded by a rising dollar and the return of volatile financial markets.

The charts below, based on data from the Bank for International Settlements (BIS), shows the increase in total debt to GDP ratios for the primary emerging markets for the past 10 years, five years and three years. Note the extremely high increase in this ratio for many countries. These increases would be remarkable under any circumstances but are especially concerning in that this has been a period of relatively low growth. Look at the example of Brazil: the very large increase in the debt was not used at all for investment and therefore will in no way produce the cash flows to service interest.

What is remarkable is how generalized and sustained the trend has been over this entire period.

China’s course is unprecedented. Though marked by the dominant role of public sector corporates and therefore, arguably, quasi-fiscal in nature, the unsustainable increase and the high level of debt raises concerns about a Japan-like “zombification” of the economy. Chile’s path is also very concerning.

India is the outstanding exception. High GDP growth, tight control over state banks and a reluctance to tap cross-border flows are the explanation, and this positions India very well for the future.

Not only have debt ratios for EM countries increased at a very high pace they are also approaching high levels in absolute terms. The rise in EM debt levels has occurred while debt levels in developed economies have been somewhat stable, rising from 251% of GDP to 276% over the past ten years. As the table below shows, China and Korea are now at levels associated with developed economies and Malaysia is not far behind.

Finally, external debt levels have also risen consistently, as shown in the charts below. If we consider a level above 30% of external debt to GDP to mark vulnerability, most EM countries find themselves in this condition, at a time when the dollar is strengthening and U.S. interest rates are rising.

Macro Watch:

  • The emergence of the petro-yuan (APJIF)
  • A users guide to future QE (PIIE)
  • Economic brake-lights (Mauldin)

Trade Wars

  • Trump pushes China to self-sufficiency (SCMP)
  • The road to confrontation (NYT)
  • The real China challenge (NYT)

India Watch

  • Election uncertainty clouds Indian stock market (FT)

China Watch:

  • China picks tobacco taxes above public health (WIC)
  • How free is China’s internet? (MERICS)

China Technology Watch

  • The Huawei security threat (Tech Review)
  • China’s Big Tech Conglomerates (IIF)
  • How China raised the stakes for EV  (WEF)
  • A profile of Bytedance, China’s short-video app (The Info)

Brazil Watch

  • John Bolton’s Troika of Tyranny (The Hill)
  • The rise of evangelicals in Latin America (AQ)

EM Investor Watch

  • In pursuit of prosperity (Mckinsey)
  • What drives the Russian state? (Carnegie)
  • Russia’s big infrastructure bet (WSJ)
  • Russia’s new pipeline (Business Week)
  • Indonesia’s elections (Lowy)
  • Chile’s renewable energy boom (Wiley)

Tech Watch

  • Bloomberg energy finance, 2018 report (Climatescope)
  • Fast-tracking zero-carbon growth (Ambition loop)
  • Why have solar energy costs fallen so quickly (VOX)
  • Asia leads in robot adoption (QZ)
  • The new industrial revolution (WSJ)

Investing