Energy Market Disruption and Global Multi-polarity

 

Around the world, energy markets are being disrupted by a combination of technology and geopolitics. On the one hand, technology is having a huge impact on supply, with shale production exploding in the United States and alternative energies (solar and wind) becoming increasingly competitive everywhere. On the other hand, growing energy self-sufficiency in the U.S. is occurring at a time when demand for oil imports is still growing quickly in emerging markets, particularly in China. As the major importer of oil in the world, China’s future economic stability will depend on secure supplies, which is forcing it to become much more pro-active in global diplomacy. China also will become uncomfortable paying for oil imports in U.S. dollars, as has been the global custom for the past 50 years. China will increasingly insist on being paid in Chinese yuan, a trend that will slowly undermine the “petrodollar system” and U.S. financial hegemony.

Over the past decade, technological innovation has permitted the exploitation of enormous U.S. shale oil and gas deposits, leading to a renaissance for the American oil industry. This, jointly with growing output of renewable energy and higher fuel efficiency, is driving the U.S. towards energy self-sufficiency. BP in its BP 2017 Energy Outlook estimates this will happen in 2023.  U.S. net imports of oil have already fallen from 13 million b/d in 2007 to 3.7 million today.

The decline in U.S. oil imports will have important consequences for global financial markets, because the U.S. pays for imported oil in dollars and the trade receipts accumulate in the world’s Central Banks and sovereign funds and is redistributed into T-bills, bank loans and other investments. Since the 1970s the global economy has been frequently buffeted by violent changes in the price of oil, leading each time to financial instability and a sharp redistribution of wealth between exporters and importers.

U.S. oil production peaked in 1970 at 10 million barrels per day and then began a precipitous decline, reaching a low of 5 million b/d in 2008. The decline in U.S. production, coming at a time of steady increases in global demand, strengthened the hand of OPEC and led to price surges in 1974 and 1980, causing stagflation in the U.S. and eventually the emerging market debt crisis of 1981. The rise of Chinese demand during the past decade created another huge surge in oil prices, with a peak in 2008 and a rebound in 2011, with enormous consequences on global liquidity and financial markets.

Oil imports have been the primary component of chronic U.S. current account deficits, representing 40.5% of cumulative deficits between 2000 and 2012, and 55% in 2012 alone. In the early 1970’s, as the major importer of oil and the global hegemon, the United States was able to convince the Saudis to price their oil in dollars, which they have done along with other OPEC members since the early 1970s. This created the “petrodollar system” as a partial substitute for the gold standard abandoned by President Nixon in 1971, guaranteeing that the dollar would remain dominant in global trade and finance.

 

However, the conditions that led to the replacement of the gold standard by the petrodollar system no longer exist in 2017. The U.S. is approaching energy self-sufficiency, while China is now the dominant oil importer in the world, with demand for imports expected to reach nearly 10 million b/d in 2018.

This is happening at a time when U.S. hegemony is on the decline, and the world is seeing multi-polar leadership, with growing Chinese and European importance.

One of the Chinese government’s expressed objectives is to increase the international influence of the yuan. In a direct challenge to American economic hegemony, China has already started using oil imports to propagate the yuan. Breaking ranks with OPEC, Nigeria in 2011 and Iran in 2012,  both started accepting yuan for oil and gas payments and accumulating yuan Central Bank reserves. Russia did the same in 2015. For both Russia and Iran, the yuan payments allow them to skirt U.S. sanctions, and for Russia this also achieves the objective of undermining U.S. dollar hegemony. Moreover, last month, Venezuela, which owes China $60 billion, announced it will price its oil in yuan.

Also, in September the Nikkei Asian Review reported that China is on the verge of launching a crude oil futures contract denominated in yuan and linked to gold. This contract would be settled in Hong Kong and Shanghai and allow Asian importers to bypass USD denominated benchmarks and could greatly strengthen the financial infrastructure necessary to promote the yuan in Asian trade.

In another interesting development, China appears to be intent on solidifying diplomatic ties with Saudi Arabia. This is of critical importance, given the crucial role the Saudi’s have in maintaining the petrodollar system. As reported by Bloomberg,  the Saudi’s are looking to tighten energy ties with China by investing $2 billion in Chinese refinery assets in exchange for China taking a major stake in the upcoming ARAMCO IPO.

All of this oil diplomacy, comes at a time when China is already achieving success in expanding the role of the yuan in global financial markets. One years ago, the International Monetary Fund agreed to a long-standing Chinese request to give the yuan official Special Drawing Rights status, joining the U.S. dollar, euro, yen, and British pound in the SDR basket. China has also successfully lobbied the MSCI to increase the weighting of Chinese stocks in its Emerging Market Index by including locally traded “A” shares, a first step towards a major integration of China’s financial market into global financial markets which will further the propagation of yuan assets in global portfolios.

Fed Watch:

  • Rajan’s view on unconventional monetary policy (Chicago Booth)
  • Low returns expected long term for U.S. stocks (Macrovoices)

India Watch:

  • Tencent wants its share in India (Caixing)
  • India’s electrical vehicle dreams (CSIS)

China Watch:

  • 7 things we learned from China in September (WEF)
  • Buffett’s bet on BYD is working (QZ)
  • Meet China’s evolving car buyer (McKinsey)

China Technology Watch:

  • China’s airplane delivery drones (China Daily)
  • China, from imitator to innovator (Forbes)
  • China leads the world in digital economy (McKinsey)

EM Investor Watch:

Technology Watch:

  • Adidas robots (Wired)
  • Acemoglu on robots (AEI)
  • Germany has more robots and stable jobs (VOX EU

Commodity Watch:

Investor Watch: