The Growing Role of the ETF in Emerging Markets Investing

ETFs, exchange-traded funds that track indices and are traded like common stocks on stock exchanges, have become enormously popular over the past decade and are an increasingly disruptive influence on the traditional asset management industry. Global ETF assets surpassed $4 trillion in 2017, growing 36% year-on-year, and 2,034 ETFs trade in the U.S. alone. Cost and liquidity are the primary attraction of ETFs, with the largest S&P500 trackers charging fees as low as 0.04% per year.  ETFs have become increasingly important as allocation instruments used by financial advisors and individual investors. Moreover, they are now commonly used by active institutional investors and traders.

Emerging Markets have seen an onslaught of ETF products. In the U.S. alone there are currently 195 EM ETFs being actively traded, representing nearly $200 billion in assets. The category is amply dominated by Global Emerging Markets (GEM) funds, with 70% of the assets. Specific country ETFs, which are widely used by active macro investors, are the second largest group, with 21% of assets. Fundamental strategies, also known as “smart beta,” make up 8% of assets. There has been a proliferation of these products, many launched by traditional active managers, which seek to exploit a specific factor (eg, value, quality, dividends, low volatility…etc.) These products are attractive to issuers because they still command relatively high fees compared to standard GEM ETSs.  The remaining categories are surprisingly insignificant. Regional funds, which used to be a fundamental part of the EM asset class, represent only 3.3% of ETFs, and are highly dominated by Asia. In contrast to the U.S., sector funds play almost no role in EM ETFs. EM sub-categories (frontier and BRIC, mainly) also are of little importance.

The EM ETF category is very dominated by four massive and growing GEM funds: Vanguard’s VWO, Blackrock’s IEMG and EEM and Schwab’s SCHE.  Fees have consistently declined for the big funds, with Schwab at the current low of 13 basis points per year. Ishares’s EEM is a complete outlier in terms of fees in this group, charging  0.72% of assets. As the first GEM fund to be launched (2003), EEM probably has legacy cost issues. For the time being, EEM can sustain this situation because its huge daily volume makes it the vehicle of choice for large hedge funds and institutional traders and investors seeking exposure to emerging markets. To compensate for the inevitable decline of EEM, Blackrock launched IEMG in 2012, with fees in-line with the competition.

Specific country funds are dominated by Blackrock’s MSCI-based ishare funds. These products maintain relatively high fees because their liquidity makes them the vehicle of choice for macro-investors, traders and allocators. Outside of the ishare products, almost all the activity of significance is in Asia where a panoply of country specific “smart beta” and sector products have been developed for China and India.

Fundamental smart beta products have also prospered in the GEM space and sustain high fees. These funds are aimed mainly at individual investors and financial advisors. Product sponsors offer “alpha-generating” factor tilts and other characteristics considered attractive to investor, such as high dividends, “quality,” low volatility, currency hedging, environmental consciousness (ESG) and leverage. The category is dominated by multi-factor funds that tilt stock allocation in favor of a combination of the value, momentum, quality and low volatility factors. The largest fundamental ETFs are listed below.

 

Us Fed watch:

India Watch:

  • India’s stock market is set for a huge bull run (Wisdom Tree)
  • Is India like East Asia or Latin America? (Livemint)

China Watch:

  • The geopolitical landscape of Asia Pacific is changing (WEF)
  • China’s ascent is slowing (Bloomberg)
  • China needs more reform to progress (Caixing)
  • Trump on the verge of trade war with China (Brookings)
  • Foreign tourists are shunning China (SCMP)

China Technology Watch:

  • New China Maglev train moves ahead (China Daily)
  • China now has 751 million internet users (Caixing)
  • China is the next tech superpower (Diamandis)
  • China targets U.S. microchip hegemony (WSJ)

EM Investor Watch:

Investor Watch:

Notable Quotes:

“I’m very optimistic about the prospects of the Artificial Intelligence industry in China, probably more so than back 20 years ago when china started with the online internet. The reason being two: one is you need data for AI development and we have tons of data whether its Alibaba’s transaction data, social network data from Wechat, etc. And on top of that when you are looking at the researchers and experts in that space many are Chinese and if you are looking at quotations in research papers the Chinese AI research in the world has a very decent market share. And so, with that I think we have a very good chance to take a lead. In fact, fundamentally what is AI in the whole science field: its mathematics and statistics and China has very strong talent in these two areas.” Sequoia China’s Neil Shen (The Economist)

“When it comes to assessing political matters (especially global geopolitics like the North Korea matter), we are very humble. We know that we don’t have a unique insight that we’d choose to bet on … We can also say that if the above things go badly, it would seem that gold (more than other safe haven assets like the dollar, yen, and treasuries) would benefit, so if you don’t have 5-10% of your assets in gold as a hedge, we’d suggest you relook at this. Don’t let traditional biases, rather than an excellent analysis, stand in the way of you doing this (and if you do have an excellent analysis of why you shouldn’t have such an allocation to gold, we’d appreciate you sharing it with us.)” Ray Dalio, Bridgewater

Notable Charts: